What are the arguments for saying that a text is postmodern or not?

             Postmodernism is a way of grouping styles of thought – and texts that present these styles – by offering a method of both constructing and deconstructing ideas, obscuring the sense of reality and playing with modernist conventions. Due to the somewhat vague and often contradictory nature of the definition of the word ‘postmodern’, one could argue that almost any text can be described as postmodern if viewed in the right way. However, there are certain characteristics that are vital in making a text postmodern, and there are also many things that mean a text cannot be described in that way.

            One argument for describing a text as postmodern is if it is self-referential or self-conscious. Postmodern texts often deliberately almost ‘make fun’ of themselves by exhibiting the fact that it is aware that it is a text, whilst modernist texts, or simply those that are not postmodern, tend to take themselves more seriously and not make references or self-parodies. For example, Lady Gaga’s music video for ‘Telephone’ can be described as postmodern as it is often self-referential: it makes references to her previous video for ‘Paparazzi’ by using similar costume choices, especially Beyonce’s glasses in the diner scene, and continuing the narrative; it makes blatant use of product placement, especially of Gaga’s own product HeartBeats; it addresses the haemaphrodite rumours about Gaga in the press. Another way that a text can be self-referential is by having the characters break the fourth wall and show that they are aware that they are in a text and that there is a world outside of it. For example, the characters Peter and Paul in the film Funny Games US often do this, such as when Paul turns to the camera and says, “You want a real ending, right, with plausible plot development, don’t you?”

Another argument for saying that a text is postmodern is through the use of pastiche and intertextual references, and the recycling of genres and styles. This means that unlike modernist ones, postmodern texts play with conventions and reverse the audience’s expectations. For example, Quentin Tarantino often uses pastiche in his films, e.g. in 1994’s Pulp Fiction, which makes constant homage to various different films and TV programmes and creates a heavy sense of nostalgia. As scholar Estella Tincknell says, the “diner setting seems to be a simulacrum of a 'fifties' restaurant...the twist contest is a musical sequence which evokes 'the sixties,' while Travolta's dance performance inevitably references 'the seventies' and his appearance in Saturday Night Fever.... The 'past' thus becomes a more general 'pastness' in which the stylistic signifiers of various decades are loaded in to a single moment." The postmodern theorist Fredric Jameson said that postmodern texts are “concerned with all surface, no substance,” which can certainly be applied to Pulp Fiction as it has been so heavily stylised and is very retro in its style.

Pulp Fiction in particular can also be described as a postmodernist text due to its incredulity towards metanarratives and the way in which the storyline of the film is made up of many smaller ones. Whilst conventional modernist texts tend to conform to the idea of metanarratives, meaning that the world is going somewhere and these stories do mean something, postmodernist texts oppose this, stating that there can be no great theories or ideas. Hence, rather than having one main simple storyline, Pulp Fiction makes use of different characters and creates many, seemingly unrelated, storylines until eventually they become intertwined. Whilst modernist films may traditionally follow an episodic narrative, postmodern ones such as Pulp Fiction often have a non-linear narrative, meaning plot events may not appear in chronological order, with the end at the beginning and the beginning at the end.

Arguably one of the simplest ways to say that a text is postmodern or not is through its humour. Postmodern texts are darkly funny, using black humour and irony extensively. An example of a black comedy film is Stanley Kubrick’s Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb, which satirised a nuclear scare. Rather than treating the subject of nuclear warfare with typical sensitivity, this film twists it into something funny. This links to a perverse sense of morality, something which is also commonly found in postmodern texts. Rather than conforming to the audience’s expectations and moral beliefs about nuclear warfare being wrong, the film toys with the idea of morality. Moreover, whilst modernist texts tend to show a very absolutist view of morality, meeting the audience’s expectations of what is right and wrong, postmodern texts often promote the idea of moral relativism, which suggests that morals can vary immensely, and that there is no objective truth as to what is right and wrong. Hence, postmodern texts show different viewpoints and perspectives rather than having a strong bias.

            Due to this warped sense of morality, often the heroes of postmodern texts are very different to the conventional heroes of modernist texts. Rather than presenting qualities that the audience considers as typically heroic or noble, postmodern characters are often anti-heroes. This means that they are flawed or unconventional, and sometimes not even likeable at all. A perfect example of an anti-hero is Alex DeLarge from Kubrick’s 1971 film A Clockwork Orange, based on the book of the same name by Anthony Burgess. In both book and film, Alex is a perverted young man that performs horrific acts of rape, murder, and “ultraviolence”, showing no remorse. Despite this, he is still the main focus of the narrative and often the audience are at times even encouraged to sympathise with him. These kinds of protagonists are yet another example of the postmodernist sense of humour and irony.

            In conclusion, there are several ways that one could argue that a text is postmodern or not, as there are many aspects of postmodernism that set it apart from the conventions of modernism. What underpins the entire postmodernist theory is the ability to recycle old ideas and make fun of not only others, but also itself. Without this sense of irony and satire, a text can hardly be described as postmodern.